Islam and Economic Performance: Historical and Contemporary Links
Journal of Economic Literature
vol. 56,
no. 4, December 2018
(pp. 1292-1359)
Abstract
This essay critically evaluates the analytic literature concerned with causal connections between Islam and economic performance. It focuses on works since 1997, when this literature was last surveyed. Among the findings are the following: Ramadan fasting by pregnant women harms prenatal development; Islamic charities mainly benefit the middle class; Islam affects educational outcomes less through Islamic schooling than through structural factors that handicap learning as a whole; Islamic finance hardly affects Muslim financial behavior; and low generalized trust depresses Muslim trade. The last feature reflects the Muslim world's delay in transitioning from personal to impersonal exchange. The delay resulted from the persistent simplicity of the private enterprises formed under Islamic law. Weak property rights reinforced the private sector's stagnation by driving capital out of commerce and into rigid waqfs. Waqfs limited economic development through their inflexibility and democratization by restraining the development of civil society. Parts of the Muslim world conquered by Arab armies are especially undemocratic, which suggests that early Islamic institutions, including slave-based armies, were particularly critical to the persistence of authoritarian patterns of governance. States have contributed themselves to the persistence of authoritarianism by treating Islam as an instrument of governance. As the world started to industrialize, non-Muslim subjects of Muslim-governed states pulled ahead of their Muslim neighbors by exercising the choice of law they enjoyed under Islamic law in favor of a Western legal system.Citation
Kuran, Timur. 2018. "Islam and Economic Performance: Historical and Contemporary Links." Journal of Economic Literature, 56 (4): 1292-1359. DOI: 10.1257/jel.20171243Additional Materials
JEL Classification
- N25 Economic History: Financial Markets and Institutions: Asia including Middle East
- N45 Economic History: Government, War, Law, International Relations, and Regulation: Asia including Middle East
- O43 Institutions and Growth
- O53 Economywide Country Studies: Asia including Middle East
- P51 Comparative Analysis of Economic Systems
- Z12 Cultural Economics: Religion