This website uses cookies.

By clicking the "Accept" button or continuing to browse our site, you agree to first-party and session-only cookies being stored on your device to enhance site navigation and analyze site performance and traffic. For more information on our use of cookies, please see our Privacy Policy.

  1. Home
  2. Journals
  3. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy
  4. Forthcoming Articles
  5. Algorithmic Risk Assessment in the Hands of Humans

American Economic Journal:
Economic Policy

ISSN 1945-7731 (Print) | ISSN 1945-774X (Online)

Algorithmic Risk Assessment in the Hands of Humans

  • Megan T. Stevenson
  • Jennifer L. Doleac
American Economic Journal: Economic Policy (Forthcoming)

Abstract

We evaluate the impact of adopting algorithmic risk assessments to inform sentencing decisions. We find that judges changed sentencing practices in response to the risk assessment, but that discretion played a large role in mediating its impact. Judges deviated from the recommendations associated with the algorithm in systematic ways, suggestive of alternative objectives at sentencing. As a result, risk assessment did not lead to detectable gains in terms of public safety or reduced incarceration rates. Using simulations, we show that strict adherence to the sentencing recommendations associated with the algorithm would have led to some benefits (a sharp reduction in incarceration) but also some costs (a slight increase in recidivism and an increase in relative sentences for the young). Discretion mitigated costs at the expense of reducing benefits.

Downloads