« Back to Results

Information Provision and Distortion in Platforms

Paper Session

Sunday, Jan. 5, 2025 8:00 AM - 10:00 AM (PST)

Hilton San Francisco Union Square, Union Square 6
Hosted By: Industrial Organization Society
  • Chair: Chiara Farronato, Harvard Business School

Platform Information Provision and Consumer Search: A Field Experiment

Yanyou Chen
,
University of Toronto
Lu Fang
,
Zhejiang University
Chiara Farronato
,
Harvard Business School
Zhe Yuan
,
Zhejiang University

Abstract

Despite substantial efforts to help consumers search in more intuitive ways, text search
remains the predominant tool for product discovery online. In this paper, we explore
the effects of visual and textual cues for search refinement on consumer search and
purchasing behavior. We collaborate with one of the largest e-commerce platforms in
China and study its roll out of a new search tool. When a customer searches for a
general term (e.g., “headphones”), the tool suggests refined queries (e.g., “bluetooth
headphones” or “noise-canceling headphones”) with the help of images and texts. The
search tool was rolled out with a long-run experiment, which allows us to measure
its short-run and long-run effects. We find that, although there was no immediate
effect on orders or total expenditures, the search tool changed customers’ search and
purchasing behavior in the long-run. Customers with access to the new tool eventually
increased orders and expenditures compared to those in the control group, especially
for non top-selling products. The purchase increase comes from more effective searches,
rather than an increase in activity on the platform. We also find that the effect is not
only driven by the direct value of suggested searches, but also by customers indirectly.

Amazon Self-Preferencing in the Shadow of the Digital Markets Act

Joel Waldfogel
,
University of Minnesota

Abstract

Regulators around the world are discussing, or taking action to limit, self-preferencing by large platforms. This paper explores Amazon's search rankings of its own products as the European Union's Digital Markets Act (DMA) was coming into effect. Using data on over 8 million Amazon search results at 22 Amazon domains in the US, Europe, and elsewhere, I document three things. First, conditional on rudimentary product characteristics, Amazon's own products receive search ranks that are 24 positions better on average throughout the sample period. Second, the Amazon rank differential is large in comparison with the differential for 142 other popular brands. Third, shortly after the EU designated Amazon a “gatekeeper” platform in September 2023, the Amazon rank differential fell from a 30 position advantage to a 20 position advantage, while other major brands' rank positions were unaffected. The changed Amazon search rankings appear in both Europe and other jurisdictions.

The Effect of Quality Disclosure on Firm Entry and Exit Dynamics: Evidence from Online Review Platforms

Ying Bao
,
University of Illinois-Urbana-Champaign
Limin Fang
,
University of British Columbia
Matthew Osborne
,
University of Toronto

Abstract

This paper examines the impact of quality disclosure on the entry and exit dynamics of firms in an industry with many firms. We develop a theoretical model highlighting two key forces: (1) direct effect, where quality disclosure influences consumers' preferences for a firm by altering perceptions of its quality, and (2) competition effect, where quality disclosure alters a firm's competitive environment by affecting perceptions of competitors' qualities. Depending on which force dominates, different scenarios emerge. For example, quality disclosure can either intensify competition so much that high-quality firms are discouraged from entry, or reduce competition such that even low-quality firms are encouraged to enter. We test the model predictions using a unique dataset on restaurant entries, exits, and online reviews in Texas from 1995 to 2015. The findings reveal varied outcomes across market types: in college towns, all firms are discouraged from entry, whereas in highway-exit markets, all firms are encouraged to enter. In other markets, high-quality firms are encouraged to enter while low-quality ones are deterred. Across all market types, young high-quality independent firms tend to stay longer, while low-quality ones exit sooner, with no significant impact on chain or established firms.

The Welfare Effects of Sponsored Product Advertising

Chuan Yu
,
Stanford University

Abstract

Many retail platforms have recently expanded their advertising businesses, featuring sponsored products in search results. While sponsored product advertising can enable sellers to reveal information, it can also worsen search results and raise prices. Using data on Amazon searches, purchases, and advertising auction bids, I estimate a model incorporating consumers, sellers, and the platform to evaluate the welfare effects. Counterfactual analysis suggests that eliminating advertising could benefit consumers and sellers under a fixed commission rate but would harm them if Amazon adjusts the rate optimally. Advertising tends to be more beneficial in markets with newer products and greater product differentiation.

Discussant(s)
Yufeng Huang
,
University of Rochester
Lawrence White
,
New York University
Sarah Moshary
,
University of California-Berkeley
Brett Hollenbeck
,
University of California-Los Angeles
JEL Classifications
  • L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance
  • L8 - Industry Studies: Services