Identity and Bias in Housing Markets
Paper Session
Sunday, Jan. 4, 2026 8:00 AM - 10:00 AM (EST)
- Chair: Neil Bhutta, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia
Appraisal and Gender
Abstract
We test for gender differences in the real estate appraisal industry. We ask whether fe-male appraisers evaluate different types of properties and whether they value the properties differently compared to their male counterparts. We largely do not find any statistically or economically significant differences between male and female appraisers using a nationwide panel of mortgages for the period 2000 to 2007. We also find that appraisers’ gender does not play a role in appraisal outcomes.
Partisan Loan Officers and the Racial Gap in Mortgage Lending
Abstract
Using a novel dataset matching mortgage loan officers' voter registration records with lending data, I find that Democratic loan officers originate 30\% more loans to minority borrowers than Republican loan officers. The results hold after controlling for loan officer location and demand-side factors. At the loan level, Democratic loan officers are more likely to originate loans with higher debt-to-income ratios to minority borrowers than Republican loan officers. Loans to minority borrowers originated by Democratic loan officers have a lower overall cost and perform better than those originated by Republican loan officers. These results suggest that Democratic loan officers collect and process more soft information to help minority borrowers overcome deficiencies in hard information, thereby expanding mortgage access for minority borrowers. These findings highlight how political ideology shapes economic outcomes through discretionary decision-making by financial intermediaries.Fear in The Neighborhood: The Cost of Racial Prejudice
Abstract
Even though policymakers and researchers tout the benefits of integration, fear of interacting with different racial groups may perpetuate segregation. Using a nearest-neighbor research design, we show that the receipt of a new Black next-door neighbor, relative to the receipt of a new White next-door neighbor, leads to an increase in 911 calls auto-dialed by home alarm systems. However, we find no change in either crime-related calls or reported crimes after the arrival of new Black neighbors. Taken together, these results suggest the presence of perceived but no actual threat to personal safety from new Black neighbors.Discussant(s)
Brent Smith
,
Virginia Commonwealth University
Lambie-Hanson Lauren
,
Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia
Erik Mayer
,
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Daniel Hartley
,
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago
JEL Classifications
- R2 - Household Analysis