The Impact of Immigration Policies on Reentry Rates Among Deportees
Abstract
While previous research has shown that interior immigration enforcement policies such as E-Verify mandates, omnibus laws, and 287(g) agreements can reduce the presence of undocumented immigrants, an important and unresolved question remains: Do these policies deter previously deported individuals from reentering the U.S., and are the deterrent effects selective, impacting immigrants with specific characteristics more than others?Our findings suggest that interior enforcement policies deter deported individuals from reentering. An increase in the Interior Enforcement Index – an index that starts at zero and increases by one unit if a state has signed at least an omnibus immigration law, a 287(g) agreement, or if E-Verify was enforced during the year- leads to a 9.7 percent decrease in reentry for all deportees and an 8.48 percent decrease for male deportees. Notably, we observed evidence of selective deterrence; these policies result in a more significant reduction in reentry rates among deportees who have been convicted of serious offenses, such as DUIs and other crimes. This finding indicates that immigration policies have strengthened the effectiveness of deportation measures, particularly for individuals whose deportation is a priority for immigration authorities.