« Back to Results

Job Search and Long-Term Unemployment

Paper Session

Sunday, Jan. 7, 2024 8:00 AM - 10:00 AM (CST)

Grand Hyatt, Lone Star Ballroom Salon B
Hosted By: American Economic Association
  • Chair: Andreas Mueller, University of Texas-Austin

The Effects of Caseworkers on Job Search Effort among the Unemployed

Johannes F. Schmieder
,
Boston University
Simon Trenkle
,
IZA and IAB
Julia Schmidtke
,
IAB
Amelie Schiprowski
,
University of Bonn

Abstract

Caseworkers play a central role in the Unemployment Insurance (UI) system of most countries by assisting and monitoring job search as well as matching job seekers with active labor market programs. In this paper we explore whether caseworkers affect job search effort among unemployed job seekers in Germany. Using high frequency panel data on search effort from the SMS survey in DellaVigna et al (2022) matched with detailed information from the public employment agencies, we explore whether job seekers increase job search effort before or after meetings with caseworkers, after being sanctioned by caseworkers, and around participation in active labor market programs. 

Risk Scores for Long-Term Unemployment and the Assignment to Job Search Counseling

Sebastian Ernst
,
London School of Economics
Andreas Mueller
,
University of Texas-Austin
Johannes Spinnewijn
,
London School of Economics

Abstract

This paper examines the predictability of long-term unemployment and the assignment to job search counseling, using data from the Belgian public employment services (PES). Building on Mueller and Spinnewijn (2023), we find substantial predictability of probability of becoming long-term unemployed based on employment and income histories as well as detailed job search data collected by the PES. We also evaluate the use of the prediction algorithm for the assignment of job seekers to job search counselors and use the variation introduced by the prediction algorithm to evaluate the effects of job search counselors.

Does Job Search Assistance Really Raise Employment?

Lionel Cottier
,
University of Lausanne
Yves Flueckiger
,
University of Geneva
Pierre Kempeneers
,
University of Geneva
Rafael Lalive
,
University of Lausanne

Abstract

We study how job search assistance (JSA) affects employment in a randomized pilot study with long run administrative data. JSA increases employment in the first year after assignment. In the second year, when most job seekers have left JSA, the employment gains evaporate, and even turn into losses in the third year. This sinusoidal pattern is consistent with job finding and employment loss transitions. Job seekers assigned to JSA find employment faster but, once employed, also lose employment faster, especially once eligible for new unemployment benefits. Job seekers assigned to JSA have similar types of contracts and re-employment earnings, but somewhat worse positions in the firm and are more likely to have a part time job.

The Impact of Work Coaches on Earnings

Robert Metcalfe
,
University of Southern California
Daniel Woodell
,
Department for Work and Pensions UK

Abstract

We investigate the impact of work coaches (WCs) on the long-term employment and earnings from the universe of job seekers in the United Kingdom. When job seekers enter the UK benefits system, they are randomly assigned a WC from their local area. Using highly-detailed administrative data, we observe the match between the job seeker and the WC, and estimate the long-term dynamics of the match. We show that the impact of WCs can explain a great deal of the variation of long-term employment and earnings outcomes. We also show how the quality of the match impacts on long-term employment and earnings outcomes and what are the predictors of match quality. 
JEL Classifications
  • J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers