Telephone service for the AEA administrative office is temporarily unavailable. For ASSA inquiries, email assa@vanderbilt.edu. For AEA inquiries, email aeainfo@vanderbilt.edu.
If you do not have access to email, please call the publications office at 412-432-2300.
« Back to Results

Determinants of Girls' Childhood Outcomes in Developing Countries

Paper Session

Tuesday, Jan. 5, 2021 12:15 PM - 2:15 PM (EST)

Hosted By: American Economic Association
  • Chair: Eric Edmonds, Dartmouth College

Reshaping Adolescents' Gender Attitudes: Evidence from a School-Based Experiment in India

Diva Dhar
,
University of Oxford
Seema Jayachandran
,
Northwestern University
Tarun Jain
,
Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad

Abstract

Societal norms about gender roles contribute to the economic disadvantages facing women in many developing countries. This paper evaluates an intervention aimed at eroding support for restrictive gender norms, specifically a multi-year school-based intervention in Haryana, India, that engaged adolescents in classroom discussions about gender equality. Using a randomized controlled trial, we find that the intervention improved adolescents' attitudes towards gender equality by 0.20 standard deviations in the short run, a sizable effect compared to other correlates of their gender attitudes such as their parents' views. The effects on progressive gender attitudes and gender-related behavior persist two years after the intervention ends; for example, boys report helping out more with household chores and girls report higher mobility.

Advancing the Agency of Adolescent Girls

Benjamin Zachary Feigenberg
,
University of Illinois-Chicago
Eric Edmonds
,
Dartmouth College
Jessica Leight
,
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)

Abstract

Can life skills be taught in early adolescence? Using a clustered randomized control
trial, this study analyzes the impact of a school-based life skills intervention in grades
six and seven within a sample of 2,459 girls in Rajasthan, India. Our evidence suggests
that the intervention is successful in developing stronger life skills including increased
agency, more equitable gender norms, and stronger socio-emotional support. Girls also
drop out of school at a lower rate: we observe an approximately 25 percent decline in
dropout that persists from seventh grade through the transition to high school.

Human Capital Investment in the Presence of Child Labor

Natalie Bau
,
University of California-Los Angeles
Martin Rotemberg
,
New York University
Bryce Steinberg
,
Brown University
Manisha Shah
,
University of California-Los Angeles

Abstract

Policies that improve early life human capital are a promising tool to alter disadvantaged children's lifelong trajectories. Yet, in many low-income countries, children and their parents make trade offs between schooling and productive work. If there are positive returns to human capital in child labor, then children who receive greater early life investments may attend less school. Exploiting early life rainfall shocks in India as a source of exogenous variation in early life investment, we show that increased early life investment leads to higher educational attainment in districts with little child labor but reduces schooling in districts with high child labor, especially among scheduled classes and women. Including controls for rich district and household level socioeconomic characteristics and school quality has little effect on these results. Similarly, the results are robust to an IV strategy that exploits variation in whether districts grow "child-friendly'' crops. The divergent effects of early life human capital investment in high and low child labor districts continue later in life, affecting fertility, per-capita household consumption, and other measures of household poverty, and persist across generations, leading to divergence in the next generations' educational outcomes. Exploiting heterogeneity in parents' incentives to invest in children by gender and birth order due to cultural traditions, we provide evidence that reductions in educational investment in response to early life shocks are inefficient.

A Stepping Stone Approach to Understanding Harmful Norms: Theory and Evidence from Somalia

Selim Gulesci
,
Bocconi University
Eliana La Ferrara
,
Bocconi University
David Smerdon
,
University of Queensland
Munshi Sulaiman
,
BRAC

Abstract

Harmful social norms often persist despite legislation against them. If the goal is to eliminate a harmful norm in the long run, can it be beneficial to introduce a `mildly harmful' alternative in the short run? We propose a discrete choice model with social interactions where individuals can choose among three traits. We provide conditions under which the intermediate trait can act as a `stepping stone' to transition to the `good' equilibrium, as opposed to becoming an absorbing state. We then validate the model assumptions using original data from Somalia, where female genital cutting (FGC) is almost universal and individuals can choose between uncut, mildly invasive cut (Sunna), and extremely invasive cut (Pharaonic). We find that people's perceptions about the prevalence of different types of FGC in their community correlate with choice and that costs and benefits of Sunna vs. Pharaonic are ranked according to model assumptions. Using a cohort analysis, we show a sharp transition from almost universal Pharaonic to almost universal Sunna in correspondence with the `entry' of the latter among the options supported by religious leaders. Finally, we show that individual intentions to cut negatively correlate with the heterogeneity in the types of FGC within their clan and community, as predicted by the model. Our analysis underlines the importance of considering intermediate alternatives when formulating policies against harmful norms.
Discussant(s)
Eric Edmonds
,
Dartmouth College
Javaeria A. Qureshi
,
University of Illinois-Chicago
Marieke Kleemans
,
University of Illinois-Urbana-Champaign
Jessica Leight
,
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
JEL Classifications
  • O1 - Economic Development
  • J1 - Demographic Economics