Tax Compliance: IRS Audit Trends for Individual Taxpayers Vary by Income (GAO-22-104960)
What GAO Found: From tax years 2010 to 2019, audit rates of individual income tax returns decreased for all income levels. On average, the audit rate for these returns decreased from 0.9 percent to 0.25 percent. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) officials attributed this trend primarily to reduced staffing as a result of decreased funding. Audit rates decreased the most for taxpayers with incomes of $200,000 and above. According to IRS officials, these audits are generally more complex and require staff's review. Lower-income audits are generally more automated, allowing IRS to continue these audits even with fewer staff.
Although audit rates decreased more for higher-income taxpayers, IRS generally audited them at higher rates compared to lower-income taxpayers, as shown in the figure. However, the audit rate for lower-income taxpayers claiming the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) was higher than average. IRS officials explained that EITC audits require relatively few resources and prevent ineligible taxpayers from receiving the EITC.
Why GAO Did This Study: IRS estimated that individual taxpayers underreported their income tax on average by $245 billion each year for tax years 2011 to 2013. This underreporting is the largest component of the tax gap—the difference between the amount of taxes owed and taxes paid timely and voluntarily.
In recent years, IRS has examined, or audited, a decreasing proportion of individual tax returns. This trend has raised concerns about the potential for declining taxpayer compliance, as well as whether IRS is equitably selecting taxpayers for audit, as audit rates for higher-income taxpayers have decreased more than audit rates for lower-income taxpayers.
GAO was asked to report on trends in IRS audit rates, audit results, and resources used for audits across individual taxpayer income levels. This report analyzes, for the most recent years available, (1) audit rates, and (2) audit results and resources used by taxpayer income.
GAO analyzed at least 10 years of data from audits of individual tax returns reporting various levels of income. GAO also analyzed 10 years of summary data related to the amount of taxes IRS collected from individual taxpayer audits. GAO interviewed IRS officials from various operating and research divisions to identify contextual factors and likely reasons for any audit trends. GAO also reviewed documentation to understand IRS's audit data, budget, and staffing.