American Economics Association

About the AEA Committees Honors & Awards For Graduate Students For Undergrad Students News & Notes Officers General Information Minutes UA Questionnaire Continuing Education Directory of Members Call for Papers Media

AEJ: Applied Economics AEJ: Economic Policy AEJ: Macroeconomics AEJ: Microeconomics American Economic Review Journal of Economic Literature Journal of Economic Perspectives eTOCs Virtual Field Journals Institutional Subscriptions AEA Journals on JSTOR Ads in Journals Back Issues Order Forms Copyright & Permissions

Submissions Registration/Housing Preliminary Program Annual Meeting Papers Annual Meeting Webcasts Disclosure Code Information Exhibitors Exhibitors & Advertisers Forms Special Events Form Continuing Education Econ-Harmony

EconLit Desktop Link EconLit for Members JEL Codes Guide JEL Classifications Journal List Contacts/Corrections Upcoming Exhibits Document Types Search Hints

JOE Listings Submit a JOE Listing Job Market Signaling Job Market Scramble Resources For Economists RFE Abridged Contents RFE Search RFE Conferences Econ Search Engine

Member Login Become a Member Directory of Members EconLit for Members AEA Journals on JSTOR Econ-Harmony Annual Meeting Webcasts Browse JEL Indexes Virtual Field Journals Institutional Subscriptions

Journal of Economic Perspectives

Search:

AEA Member Login:

Quick Tools:

View Full Text of This Article

Email Link to this Article Export Citation

Sign up for Email Alerts

Follow us on Twitter

Post a Comment on this Article (AEA Members Only)

View Comments on this Article

Article Abstract and Tools

Subscription Information
(Institutional Administrator Access)

Explore:

JEP - Previous Issues
JEP - Winter 2005

JEL Indexes (Members Only)

Journal of Economic Perspectives

Vol. 19, No. 1, Winter 2005

The Making of an Economist Redux David Colander
Article Citation
Colander, David. 2005. "The Making of an Economist Redux." Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19(1): 175–198.
DOI:10.1257/0895330053147976
Abstract
This paper reports the findings of a survey and interviews with graduate students at seven top-ranking graduate economics programs. It finds that over the last 15 years graduate economics programs have become more empirical, less mathematical and less theoretically oriented, and that the students are generally positive about the profession. It also finds fewer differences among school. Despite the improvements, and greater student satisfaction, the paper suggests that there are serious pedagogical questions about the focus of the core on mathematical techniques rather than on creativity and economic reasoning, which students see as the true core of economics.

Article Full-Text Access

Full-Text Article (Complimentary)

JEP Discussion Forum

View Comments on This Article (0) | Post A Comment on This Article (AEA Members)

Authors

Colander, David

© 2012 AEA. The American Economic Association is hosted by Vanderbilt University.